Reinforcement and Punishment in Teaching: Pros & Cons

The management of the classroom can be a very difficult aspect of teaching. It can be challenging to keep 20–30 pupils quiet, interested, and eager to learn. The teacher must maintain control over the students’ behavior for the learning process to run smoothly. In order for students to know exactly what actions are anticipated in the classroom, it is also crucial to set clear expectations for them. The same concepts of reinforcement and punishment that can be used at home can also be applied to managing behaviors at school.

Using Reinforcement Classroom

A consequence after an action that raises the likelihood that the behavior will rise in the future is known as reinforcement.

Reinforcement in the classroom should be used to keep students engaged and motivated to learn in addition to managing conduct. To establish a positive learning atmosphere and to encourage appropriate classroom behavior, teachers should frequently use reinforcement.

Also Read: How to Pass Exams Without Studying in 2022

Forms of Reinforcement

Positive Reinforcement: A consequence that includes “Positive Reinforcement” will lead to more of that particular conduct in the future.

Example: You give your child a cookie as a reward after he cleans his room the first time you ask. He will likely tidy his room the first time you ask him to in the future.

Negative reinforcement: This is anything unrelated to the outcome that makes the behavior more likely to occur in the future.

Example: After the class performs well on the arithmetic test, the teacher decides not to assign homework for the following day.

Negative reinforcement is frequently misunderstood and mistaken for punishment. But as you can see from the description and illustration above, negative reinforcement is utilized to encourage desired behaviors and is in no way punitive.

Examples of Reinforcement:

The following are some examples of reinforcers that can be used in the classroom:

• Teacher acclaim
• Gaining advantages
• Teaching focus
• Taking a homework assignment with you
• Additional break time
• Adding time to a deadline

Using Punishment in the Classroom:

Punishment is a response to behavior that lessens the likelihood that the same action will be taken again in the future.

To reduce disruptive behaviors in the classroom, punishment should be employed. Care must be taken when using punishment in the classroom; it should never be used to target particular pupils or to reprimand actions brought on by a particular impairment. It is crucial to seek further help if a student exhibits challenging behaviors as a result of a disability so that a behavior plan specifically for that child can be created.

If punishment is necessary, it should be of the least restrictive kind. In general, reinforcement should be the main strategy used in the classroom. It is crucial to consult your school’s policy on proper classroom management techniques and what is and is not permitted in your particular school before employing any punishment tactics.

Also Read: Work for Google: 5 simple tips to getting hired

Types of Punishment:

Positive Punishment: This is an addition to the consequence that reduces a particular conduct going forward.

Example: You punish your child for interrupting you by making them perform extra tasks.

Negative Punishment: When a punishment involves taking away something or a privilege that will make the behavior less likely to occur again in the future.

As an illustration, you might take away your child’s phone for a week if they fail a test.

Examples of Punishment:

The following are some examples of sanctions that have been applied in classrooms:

• Reduction in break time
• Added homework
• Other privileges are lost
• Detention

Sending a student to a solitary time-out room or depriving them of their lunch or snack are two examples of harsher and more unsuitable sanctions.

Systems of classroom-wide behavior control that include punishment and reinforcement are frequently used by teachers. Because they can be easily implemented and the students know exactly what is expected of them, these systems are quite popular in many classrooms.

Classroom-wide behavior management systems that utilize both Reinforcement and Punishment:

Stoplights Management System:

In the classroom, there are moveable buttons or clothespins with each student’s name on them, as well as a sizable stoplight with the colors green, yellow, and red. Each day, the students start off on the color green, but depending on how they behave, they may go to yellow or red. The kids who are still on green at the conclusion of the day are given a reward or privilege.

The Token Economy:

a system for changing behavior in which pupils receive tokens for carrying out particular actions and can swap those tokens for desired products at a predetermined period.

Group Contingencies:

These kinds of contingencies take place when a single punishment is meted out depending on the conduct or performance of either a subset of students or the entire class. Group contingencies come in three different varieties.

1. Independent Group Scene: 

All of the students in the class have access to rewards, but only those who fulfill the requirements actually receive them.

2. Dependent Groups Contingency:

The actions or performance of one particular student or small group determines the prize for the entire group.

3. Interdependence Group Contingency

Before receiving a prize, each student in the class must first fulfill the requirements (both individually and collectively).

Tips for using Reinforcement

1. Always be mindful to only provide praise to actions that you want to reinforce and continue in the future. Without realizing it, it is simple to unintentionally reward negative behaviors (for example, your child may be sobbing in the grocery store because you won’t give them candy). The next time they ask for candy at the grocery store, they’re going to cry because you eventually cave and buy it for them. In this instance, sobbing was a behavior that was favorably reinforced, ensuring that it would persist in the future.
2. Change the kind of reinforcement applied to prevent overindulgence in a specific good or activity (i.e., if you always reward your child with candy for good behavior, they are likely to get tired of the candy and may stop engaging in the desired behavior).
3. Determine your child’s current motivation before selecting a reinforcer, then employ that thing. Others might switch their motivation more regularly, while some kids can stay motivated by the same thing for extended lengths of time.
4. Deliver reinforcement in a consistent manner to maintain the desired behavior.

Also Read: Helping Child Amputee: Academically & Psychologically 6 Steps

Tips for Using Punishment in Teaching

1. Just punish actions that you want to see less of. It is possible to unintentionally punish suitable behaviour in addition to unintentionally reinforcing undesirable conduct.
2. Always make sure to keep rewarding appropriate behaviors while deterring the undesirable behavior.
3. Reconsider the consequence and try another one if you find yourself utilizing punishment and the behavior is not improving. Additionally, the punishment your child receives this week might not be applied the next week. According to your child’s present motivation, you should constantly reassess what reinforcers to utilize as well as what negative consequences to apply.
4. Deliver punishments consistently in order to reduce undesirable behavior.

FAQs about Reinforcement and Punishment

TOP PICKS FOR YOU:

• How To Become A Bitcoin Miner In 2023 | A Guide to Bitcoin Mining
• How to become a CRNA: Salary, Duties & Work Environment
• 10 Best Trade Schools for Plumbing in 2023
• 15 Top Art Therapy Universities